Comment 15 (10 May 2022) – comments and feedback

Garrett Hurst

Okay, I'm finally at home, and have a chance to type out all four plans in order. Attached are also the links to the plans as a .csv file. I used www.election-atlas.ca/ridingbuilder to create the ridings, and you can also import the below-attached files into the aformentioned site to see the plan outright. (sorry, I would have tried a better service, but I'm not sure how to be honest). I approximated my plan as much as I could, as I had not exported my maps when I made them, but when I remade them I couldn't get them exactly the same. Either way, here you go.

Plan 1:

1. Red: Winnipeg South: 93,876(-2.82%)
2. Dark Blue: Charleswood--Tuxedo: 98,043(+1.63%)
3. Lime Green: Winnipeg--Fort Garry: 93,084(-2.76%)
4. Yellow: Winnipeg: St. Boniface--Southdale: 96,547(+0.08%)
5. Magenta: Elmwood--Transcona: 94,496(-2.05%)
6. Teal: Winnipeg Centre: 99,083(+2.71%)
7. Orange: Tyndall Park--The Maples: 95,909(-0.58%)
8. Grey: Winnipeg--North Kildonan: 94,386(-2.16%)
9. Pink: Provencher: 98,210(+1.8%)
10. Turquoise: Selkirk--Beausejour--Interlake: 99,434(+3.07%)
11. Rural Yellow: Portage--Lisgar: 96,838(+0.38%)
12. Maroon: Brandon--Souris: 96,070(-0.41%)
13. Beige: Dauphin--Swan River: 96,842(+0.39%)
14. Light Blue: Churchill--Keewatinook Aski: 97,137(+0.69%)

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the Province of Manitoba broken down into 14 proposed federal electoral districts under Plan 1. Each colour corresponds to one electoral district, with its proposed name, as well as what its population and variance from the Electoral Quota would be.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of southern Manitoba under Plan 1.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of Winnipeg under Plan 1.

Plan 2:

1. Red: Churchill--Keewatinook Aski: 97,918 (+1.50%)
2. Dark Blue: Brandon--Souris: 96,611 (+0.15%)
3. Lime Green: Dauphin--Swan Lake: 97,446 (+1.01%)
4. Yellow (rural): Steinbach--Stanley: 96,886 (+0.43%)
5. Magenta: Portage--Gimli: 96,870 (+0.42%)
6. Teal: Selkirk--Eastman--Pinawa: 98,800 (+2.42%)
7. Orange: Charleswood--St. James: 96,669 (+0.21%)
8. Grey: Kildonan--St. Paul: 96,354 (-0.12%)
9. Pink: Winnipeg North: 93,843 (-3.09%)
10. Turquoise: Winnipeg Centre: 96,287 (-0.19%)
11. Yellow (urban): Elmwood--Transcona: 96,838 (-0.1%)
12. Maroon: St. Vital--St. Boniface: 96,070 (-0.41%)
13. Beige: Winnipeg--Fort Garry: 95,426 (-1.08%)
14. Light Blue: Winnipeg South: 96,008 (-0.48%)

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the Province of Manitoba broken down into 14 proposed federal electoral districts under Plan 2. Each colour corresponds to one electoral district, with its proposed name, as well as what its population and variance from the Electoral Quota would be.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of southern Manitoba under Plan 2.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of Winnipeg under Plan 2.

Plan 3:

1. Red: Churchill--Keewatinook Aski: 97,918 (+1.50%)
2. Dark Blue: Brandon--Souris: 96,611 (+0.15%)
3. Lime Green: Dauphin--Swan Lake: 97,446 (+1.01%)
4. Yellow (rural): Steinbach--Stanley: 96,886 (+0.43%)
5. Magenta: Portage--Gimli: 96,870 (+0.42%)
6. Teal: Selkirk--Eastman--Pinawa: 98,800 (+2.42%)
7. Orange: Charleswood--St. James: 96,582 (+0.12%)
8. Grey: Winnipeg Centre: 96,279 (-0.20%)
9. Pink: Winnipeg North: 96,593 (+0.13%)
10. Turquoise: Kildonan--St. Paul: 96,602 (+0.13%)
11. Yellow (urban): Elmwood--Transcona: 96,119 (-0.36%)
12. Maroon: St. Vital--St. Boniface: 94,182 (-2.37%)
13. Beige: Winnipeg--Fort Garry: 95,429 (-1.08%)
14. Light Blue: Winnipeg South: 94,228 (-2.32%)

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the Province of Manitoba broken down into 14 proposed federal electoral districts under Plan 3. Each colour corresponds to one electoral district, with its proposed name, as well as what its population and variance from the Electoral Quota would be.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of southern Manitoba under Plan 3.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of Winnipeg under Plan 3.

Plan 4:

1. Red: Provencher: 96,919(+0.47%)
2. Dark Blue: Portage--Lisgar: 96,142(+0.15%)
3. Lime Green: Brandon--Borderlands: 96,473(+0.01%)
4. Yellow (rural): Dauphin--Swan Lake: 96,439(-0.03%)
5. Magenta: Selkirk--Interlake--Whiteshell: 99,401(+3.04%)
6. Teal: Churchill--Keewatinook Aski: 98,800(+2.79%)
7. Orange: St James--Tuxedo: 96,713(+0.25%)
8. Grey: Winnipeg Centre: 96,616(+0.15%)
9. Pink: Winnipeg--River Heights: 96,759(+0.30%)
10. Turquoise: Winnipeg--Saint Vital--Waverley: 96,659(+0.20%)
11. Yellow (urban): St Boniface--Southdale: 96,284(-0.19%)
12. Maroon: Elmwood--Transcona: 96,394(-0.08%)
13. Beige: Winnipeg North: 94,673(-1.86%)
14. Light Blue: Kildonan--St. Paul: 91,916(-4.72%)

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the Province of Manitoba broken down into 14 proposed federal electoral districts under Plan 4. Each colour corresponds to one electoral district, with its proposed name, as well as what its population and variance from the Electoral Quota would be.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of southern Manitoba under Plan 4.

Image description provided by Elections Canada: This map shows the proposed federal electoral districts of Winnipeg under Plan 4.