Comment 1 (22 February 2022) – comments and feedback
Back to all comments and feedback from the public
The documents below are posted in the official language in which they were received.
Alan Hall
Subject: A New Electoral Map for Canada
Hello,
Here is my proposal for 342 federal electoral districts across Canada.
The proposed ridings use population counts from the 2021 Census recently released by Statistics Canada. I will update this map periodically with revised boundaries if I find a better alternative.
Also, there's an interesting discussion about the federal redistribution going on here:
https://talkelections.org/FORUM/index.php?topic=467200.0
I will not be participating in the public hearings.
However, I wish to present a revised alternative proposal for the Commission to consider.
Sincerely,
Alan Hall
Additional comment received on 2 August 2022
In contrast to the Commission's proposal, my alternative would:
- keep the City of Saint John united in a single riding
- set the population of each electoral district as close as reasonably possible to the electoral quota (77,561)
- maintain the bilingual nature of New Brunswick by keeping three ridings with over 60% French mother tongue, and significantly increase the French share of the population of Moncton--Dieppe (from 36% to 45%)
Please see the tables below.
Federal Electoral District − Commission | Population 2021 | Variance% |
---|---|---|
Moncton—Dieppe | 91,333 | +17.8% |
Beauséjour | 88,490 | +14.1% |
Fredericton—Oromocto | 85,540 | +10.3% |
Saint John—Kennebecasis | 81,954 | +5.7% |
Acadie—Bathurst | 79,581 | +2.6% |
Saint John—St. Croix | 78,963 | +1.8% |
Fundy Royal—Riverview | 74,261 | −4.3% |
Madawaska—Restigouche | 71,099 | −8.3% |
Tobique—Mactaquac | 64,664 | −16.6% |
Miramichi—Grand Lake | 59,725 | −23.0% |
Federal Electoral District - Commission | Population 2016 | French MT% |
---|---|---|
Acadie—Bathurst | 66,230 | 82.9% |
Madawaska—Restigouche | 57,190 | 79.9% |
Beauséjour | 50,965 | 62.6% |
Moncton—Dieppe | 29,725 | 35.6% |
Miramichi—Grand Lake | 11,820 | 19.9% |
Fredericton—Oromocto | 6,505 | 8.0% |
Fundy Royal—Riverview | 3,375 | 4.8% |
Saint John—Kennebecasis | 3,430 | 4.4% |
Tobique—Mactaquac | 2,690 | 4.3% |
Saint John—St. Croix | 3,000 | 3.9% |
Federal Electoral District − Alternative | Population 2021 | Variance% |
---|---|---|
Saint John—Grand Bay−Westfield | 81,908 | +5.6% |
Fundy Royal—Moncton West | 80,772 | +4.1% |
Fredericton | 80,524 | +3.8% |
Moncton East—Dieppe | 80,379 | +3.6% |
Acadie—Bathurst | 79,581 | +2.6% |
Miramichi—Tobique—Grand Lake | 76,611 | −1.2% |
Gagetown—Kennebecasis | 76,489 | −1.4% |
Beauséjour | 76,155 | −1.8% |
Federal Electoral District − Alternative | Population 2016 | French MT% |
---|---|---|
Acadie—Bathurst | 66,230 | 82.9% |
Madawaska—Grand Falls—Restigouche | 57,190 | 79.9% |
Beauséjour | 43,730 | 60.9% |
Moncton East—Dieppe | 32,070 | 44.9% |
Miramichi—Tobique—Grand Lake | 12,850 | 17.0% |
Fundy Royal—Moncton West | 7,775 | 10.2% |
Fredericton | 5,690 | 7.5% |
Gagetown—Kennebecasis | 4,170 | 5.7% |
Sincerely,
Alan Hall