Comment 60 – comments and feedback

Charla Robinson, President of the Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce

I am writing to express my deep concerns with the proposed riding redistribution that would see Northern Ontario reduced to 9 ridings from the current 10 riding allocation. This proposal will result in a reduction of representation for our citizens that will lessen our voice on issues within the region. A significant number of Northern Ontario communities do not have a Service Canada Centre, a passport office or an Immigration office and rely on the local Member of Parliament constituency office to assist with these requirements.

Under the new proposal, the riding of Kenora-Thunder Bay-Rainy River includes 55 communities and is over 13 hours by car to travel across. It would be impossible for one MP to effectively represent so many communities and would take nearly two months to undertake even a one-day visit to each community for constituency matters. Similarly, the riding of Kiiwetinoong-Mushkegowuk covers over 520,000 square kilometres in which most of the communities are only accessible by air. The proposal indicates that it is "accessible via regular flight routes" but does not consider the significant time and cost involved due to limited flight schedules.

This proposal is a clear indication of a significant lack of understanding of the challenges faced by Northern Ontarians. Population cannot be the only metric used to determine electoral representation as the calculations must also consider the distances and infrastructure limitations involved that will impact our representation. Future electoral riding commissions should be mandated to travel to all the communities that will be affected by a significant riding boundary change prior to publishing their proposal.

Thank you for your consideration of my concerns. It is my hope that this proposal will be rejected and that the current 10 federal ridings will remain in place.

Charla Robinson

Re: Federal redistribution process as provided in the Electoral Boundaries Readjustment Act

Dear Ms. Puddy:

On behalf of the Northern Chambers of Commerce, which comprises the cities of Timmins, Greater Sudbury, North Bay and District, Sault Ste. Marie, and Thunder Bay, we are writing to share the perspective of our combined 3500 members on the constitutionally-triggered decennial census on the redistribution of Federal Electoral Districts 2022. As you are well aware, the 2022 redistribution proposal calls for Northern Ontario's federal ridings to be reduced from 10 to nine ridings with re-drawn lines that would impact nearly every community in the region. At present, the act outlines the process of utilizing the electoral quotient tools as a simple numbers game and reads:

"In relation to the readjustment following the completion of any subsequent decennial census, the number obtained by multiplying the electoral quotient that was applied in the preceding readjustment by the number that is the average of the numbers obtained by dividing the population of each province by the population of the province as at July 1 of the year of the preceding decennial census according to the estimates prepared for the purpose of the preceding readjustment, and rounding up any fractional remainder of that multiplication to one."

While we appreciate the use of this quotient to redefine the boundaries, it is critical to note the unintended consequences of applying this tool to redistribute the current federal ridings. It removes an elected Member of Parliament and subsequently a voice from an already underrepresented region of the country.

Conducting business in Northern Ontario already comes with challenges, given our vast geographical distances, supply chain constraints, out-migration and population decline, and the impact of long winter seasons and freeze-thaw cycles on our infrastructure. Furthermore, our ability to advocate through our members of parliament would be reduced, which would pose a challenge to business organizations and their ability to serve their members' needs.

Removing a representative and expanding the current boundaries could potentially impede political participation by Indigenous peoples living in these remote and rural regions by presenting new barriers due to the vast geographical size of even the current ridings. The new proposed boundary lines would further exacerbate challenges in an already expansive territory, not to mention the challenge that would pose for any one representative to cover the issues of that entire geographical area. More importantly, the Northern Chambers also find this constitutionally-triggered process to be archaic and unintentionally discriminatory by not accounting for underrepresented and underserviced groups in the region deserving of equity. Our business members also hold this concern in high regard, given their strong commitment to principles of economic reconciliation.

The Northern Chambers of Commerce wishes to use this opportunity to call on Elections Canada to reject the proposal to remove one riding from Northern Ontario. Our businesses recognize the importance of fair and equitable representation in parliament and the importance of economic reconciliation— something that would be burdensome with the removal of a Northern riding. The Indigenous are Canada's fastest growing population, not only leading strong, legacy enterprises in their own right but lending to new and innovative practices that support and bolster business and their workforce. Elections Canada must commit to principles of Truth and Reconciliation, and an important step would be maintaining the current number of ridings in Northern Ontario.

Should you have any questions or comments, I invite you to contact me, Keitha Robson, via email: at krobson@timminschamber.on.ca or by phone at 705.360.1900. Thank you for your time and consideration in these important consultations.

Sincerely,

Keitha Robson Chief Administrative Officer Timmins Chamber

Dan Ayotte 2022-23 President Timmins Chamber

Debbi Nicholson, President & CEO of the Greater Sudbury Chamber of Commerce

Rory Ring, CEO of the Sault Ste Marie Chamber of Commerce

Donna Backer, Interim President and CEO of the North Bay and District Chamber of Commerce

Charla Robinson, President of the Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce

Cc. MP Charlie Angus, Timmins–James Bay MP Viviane Lapointe, Sudbury MP Marc Serré, Nickel Belt MP Anthony Rota, Nipissing-Timiskaming MP Carol Hughes, Algoma-Manitoulin-Kapuskasing MP Terry Sheehan, Sault Ste. Marie MP Patty Hajdu, Thunder Bay–Superior North MP Marcus Powlowski, Thunder Bay–Rainy River MP Eric Melillo, Kenora Northern Ontario Media Outlets